Neutron measurement guide

Neutron Detection Methods Compared

Neutrons carry no charge, so no detector sees them directly. Every neutron detector first converts the neutron into a charged particle, through capture in helium-3, boron-10 or lithium-6, a recoiling proton, fission, or activation, and then detects that. The conversion you choose decides the detector's efficiency, energy range, gamma sensitivity and cost.

This guide compares the main methods, active and passive: helium-3 and BF3 tubes, boron-lined counters, lithium-6 and organic scintillators, fission chambers, Bonner spheres, activation foils, bubble detectors, albedo TLDs and CR-39 track detectors.

By Noah D'Amico, PhD, BlankSlate Innovation · Last reviewed 18 November 2026

Starting point

How Do Neutron Detectors Convert a Neutron?

Six conversion mechanisms cover almost every neutron detector in use. Capture reactions favor slow neutrons, which is why detectors for fast neutrons are often wrapped in a hydrogen-rich moderator to slow them down first.

Conversion Reaction Thermal cross-section Best for
Helium-3 captureHe-3(n,p)T, releasing 0.764 MeVAbout 5,330 barnsThermal neutrons; fast neutrons after moderation
Boron-10 captureB-10(n,alpha)Li-7, releasing 2.31 MeV in 94% of capturesAbout 3,840 barnsThermal and epithermal neutrons
Lithium-6 captureLi-6(n,t)alpha, releasing 4.78 MeVAbout 940 barnsThermal neutrons, in scintillators and TLDs
Proton recoilElastic scattering on hydrogenNot a capture reactionFast neutrons, roughly 100 keV and up
FissionU-235(n,f), releasing about 200 MeVAbout 585 barnsVery high flux and harsh environments
ActivationA capture or threshold reaction that leaves a radioactive productDepends on the foilTime-integrated fluence in any field

Live readout

Active Neutron Detectors Compared

Active detectors produce an electrical pulse for each detected neutron, so they give count rate and, in some cases, timing and energy.

Method How it works Strengths Limits Typical use
Helium-3 proportional counterHe-3 gas captures thermal neutrons; a moderator slows fast ones firstHighest thermal efficiency per volume. Excellent gamma rejection. Stable and long-livedHelium-3 is scarce and expensive. Needs high voltage. Moderated counting loses energy informationSafeguards, portal monitors, neutron scattering, well logging
BF3 proportional counterBoron trifluoride gas, enriched in boron-10Cheaper than helium-3. Good gamma rejectionBF3 is toxic and corrosive. Lower efficiency per tube. Higher operating voltageArea monitors, older reactor and survey instruments
Boron-lined counterA thin solid boron-10 coating on tube or straw wallsNon-toxic and uses no helium-3. Scales to large areasLower efficiency per tube, so more tubes are neededHelium-3 replacement in portal monitors
Lithium-6 scintillators (Li glass, LiF/ZnS, CLYC)Capture in lithium-6 produces a flash of lightCompact and fast. CLYC measures gammas and neutrons in one crystalLi glass is gamma-sensitive. LiF/ZnS screens are opaque, which limits thickness. CLYC is costlyHandheld instruments, neutron imaging, scattering instruments
Organic scintillators (liquid, plastic, stilbene)Fast neutrons scatter off hydrogen, and the recoil protons make lightNanosecond timing. Energy spectra by time of flight or unfolding. Pulse-shape discrimination separates neutrons from gammasGamma-sensitive without pulse-shape discrimination. Poor for thermal neutrons. Some liquids are flammable or toxicFast-neutron spectroscopy, time of flight, fusion and accelerator work
Fission chamberNeutrons fission a thin uranium coatingVery wide dynamic range. Radiation-hard and gamma-insensitiveLow efficiency. Contains fissile material, with the licensing that followsReactor power monitoring, tokamak yield monitors
Bonner sphere spectrometerA thermal detector placed inside moderating spheres of several sizesCovers thermal to hundreds of MeV with one systemPoor energy resolution. The spectrum must be unfolded. Slow, with many measurementsWorkplace and accelerator field characterization

Read afterwards

Passive Neutron Detectors Compared

Passive detectors have no active electronics during the exposure. They cannot saturate electronically, pile up or pick up noise, and they give only one number per exposure: total flux.

Method How it works Strengths Limits Typical use
Activation foils (gold, indium and others)Neutrons make the foil radioactive, and a gamma counter reads it afterwardsAbsolute fluence. No electronics during exposure. Unaffected by gammas, EMP or pulse rateTime-integrated. Needs a gamma spectrometer and prompt counting. Each foil covers one energy regionReactor and accelerator flux mapping, pulsed sources, calibrations
Bubble detectorsNeutrons trigger visible bubbles in a superheated gelRead by eye in minutes. Gamma-insensitive. Reusable for a limited number of cyclesTemperature-dependent. Limited dynamic range and shelf lifePersonal and area dosimetry, quick surveys
Albedo TLD dosimetersLithium-6 and lithium-7 thermoluminescent chips read the neutrons scattered back by the bodySmall, reusable and cheap per reading. Established for personnel dosimetryStrongly energy-dependent. Needs the wearer's body as moderator, and site-specific calibrationRoutine personnel neutron dosimetry
CR-39 track detectorsRecoil protons leave etchable tracks; a boron coating adds thermal responseInsensitive to gammas, X-rays and EMP. Permanent record. Small and cheap enough to deploy by the hundredLow efficiency: roughly 1 in 10,000 to 1 in 1,000,000 for bare plastic. Time-integrated. Needs etching and track countingPersonnel dosimetry, pulsed and mixed fields, fusion experiments, long unattended exposures

Decision table

Which Neutron Detector Should You Use?

Situation Good choices Why
Counting thermal neutrons at a steady rateHelium-3, boron-lined or BF3 countersHigh capture cross-section and clean gamma rejection
Fast-neutron timing or spectraOrganic scintillatorsNanosecond response and pulse-shape discrimination
Intense pulses, strong gamma or EMPActivation foils, CR-39, bubble detectorsPassive detectors cannot pile up or pick up noise
Many positions on a small budgetCR-39, activation foilsLow cost per position and no cabling
Long unattended exposuresCR-39No power, and the record is permanent
Personnel dosimetryAlbedo TLDs, CR-39, bubble detectorsSmall, wearable and passive
Unknown spectrum over a wide energy rangeBonner spheresOne system covers thermal to very high energies
Extreme flux and radiation damageFission chambersWide dynamic range and radiation hardness

Supply

Why Is Helium-3 Scarce?

Helium-3 has been the reference neutron-detector gas for decades. Almost all commercial helium-3 comes from the radioactive decay of tritium held in national stockpiles, so supply is set by how much tritium exists and not by demand. After 2001, large numbers of radiation portal monitors were deployed, demand outran supply, and by 2008 to 2009 the shortage was acknowledged and helium-3 was being allocated. That is what drove the boron-lined, BF3 and lithium-6 alternatives in the tables above.

A second possible source is natural gas, since some helium-bearing gas contains measurable helium-3. Finding it takes a mass spectrometer that can separate helium-3 from HD at mass 3. See helium-3 testing for natural gas.

Available here

One of These Methods Is Made in Lubbock, Texas

BlankSlate Innovation manufactures CR-39 track detectors for passive neutron detection: bare for fast neutrons, and boron-nitride coated for thermal and epithermal neutrons. Standard CR-39 is $2/cm2 and boron-coated is $5/cm2.

We measured a bare-CR-39 efficiency of about 4 × 10-5 at 14 MeV, and the coating results are peer-reviewed (reference 4). CR-39 will not replace a helium-3 tube for live counting. It is the right tool when the field is pulsed, mixed or unpowered.

Order CR-39 · SSNTD materials guide · Fusion diagnostics methods compared · Talk to our team

Questions people ask

Neutron Detection FAQ

What is the best neutron detector?

There is no single best neutron detector. Helium-3 proportional counters give the highest thermal-neutron efficiency with excellent gamma rejection. Organic scintillators are best for fast-neutron timing and spectra. Passive detectors such as activation foils, bubble detectors and CR-39 are best in pulsed, high-gamma or unpowered settings. The right choice depends on neutron energy, rate, gamma background, and whether real-time readout is needed.

Why is helium-3 used in neutron detectors?

Helium-3 captures thermal neutrons with a very large cross-section, about 5,330 barns, and releases a proton and a triton that are easy to detect in a gas proportional counter. The gas is non-toxic, the tubes are stable for decades, and gamma rays produce much smaller pulses, so they are easy to reject. Its drawback is scarcity: helium-3 is a by-product of tritium decay.

What can replace helium-3 for neutron detection?

The main alternatives are boron-lined proportional counters, boron trifluoride tubes, and lithium-6 scintillators such as LiF/ZnS screens, lithium glass and CLYC crystals. Each has lower efficiency per unit volume than pressurized helium-3, so replacements usually use more detector area. For time-integrated measurements, passive methods such as activation foils and boron-coated CR-39 need no helium-3 at all.

How do you detect neutrons in a strong gamma or pulsed radiation field?

Use a passive detector. Activation foils, bubble detectors and CR-39 track detectors do not respond to gamma rays or electromagnetic pulse and cannot pile up, because they have no electronics during the exposure. They give a time-integrated result. If timing is needed, a shielded organic scintillator with pulse-shape discrimination is added at a distance.

Can CR-39 detect neutrons?

Yes, indirectly. Fast neutrons knock protons out of the plastic, and each recoil proton leaves an etchable track. Bare CR-39 detects roughly one neutron in 10,000 to one in 1,000,000, depending on energy. A boron converter coating adds thermal and epithermal sensitivity through the boron-10 capture reaction. CR-39 is time-integrated and must be etched and read after exposure.

Sources

References and Further Reading

  1. G. F. Knoll, Radiation Detection and Measurement, 4th ed., Wiley, 2010.
  2. R. T. Kouzes et al., "Neutron detection alternatives to 3He for national security applications," Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research A 623, 1035 (2010). doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2010.08.021
  3. D. A. Shea and D. Morgan, "The Helium-3 Shortage: Supply, Demand, and Options for Congress," Congressional Research Service Report R41419, 2010.
  4. N. D'Amico et al., "Boron nitride coatings for the enhanced detection of neutrons in CR-39," Nuclear Engineering and Technology 58, 104027 (2026). doi.org/10.1016/j.net.2025.104027
  5. J. A. Frenje et al., "Absolute measurements of neutron yields from DD and DT implosions at the OMEGA laser facility using CR-39 track detectors," Review of Scientific Instruments 73, 2597 (2002). doi.org/10.1063/1.1487889